The Giants scored 38 points and had over 500 yards of offense ... and lost. There's something wrong here, and it's not just Bill Sheridan's fault, although his defense was atrocious again and he deserves to be thrown into the East River with a cinderblock tied to his ankle.
Still, if you give up a defensive touchdown and a special teams touchdown, you're not going to win very many games, and those were only two of what felt like a dozen mistakes the Giants made last night against Philly. That game was an example of everything wrong with the Giants this season.
Every time the Giants looked like they were back in the game, they would come up small. The defense let Philly drive right down the field after the opening kickoff, probably the easiest six-play, 67-yard touchdown drive you'll ever see. Then Brandon Jacobs' fumble turned into a Sheldon Brown touchdown, and before I could even finish my first beer, the Giants were down 14-0.
Eli Manning did his best to keep them in the game and thanks to some god-awful tackling by the Eagles' secondary, Hakeem Nicks's 68-yard catch-and-run got the Giants within 14-10.
It was 17-10 when DeSean Jackson, who seems to be taking over for Brian Westbrook as the Eagle who absolutely kills us at every opportunity, made his first big play of the game. Now, I am not a special teams coach, but from everything I know about football, you want the punt returner to field the ball near the sideline in order to prevent him from having too many options about where to run.
Sound strategy, yes. Of course, when your coverage unit forgets the critical element of TACKLING the returner, someone like Jackson gets to run 72 yards untouched to the end zone.
Eli and the offense answered with yet another touchdown drive late in the half to once again get within a touchdown, and it was time for the defense to suffer their own brain fart.
Osi made his first big play in ages by stripping the ball out of McNabb's hands and into the air. Yes, Michael Boley should have caught it and scored the tying touchdown, but he didn't, and the ball then sat there, and sat there ... and sat there.
Maybe they were all just stunned that Osi managed to find himself in the same zipcode as an opposing quarterback, but for whatever reason, nobody picked it up. The play was eventually blown dead, and the Eagles again shoved the ball down our throats for a 30-17 halftime lead.
Amazingly, the Giants were ahead 31-30 less than 10 minutes into the third quarter, a lead that lasted exactly 15 seconds. McNabb to Jackson, 60 yards, touchdown.
It was another failure of the blitz to generate any pressure whatsoever, and of the secondary to even come within five yards of Jackson down the field. How many times are they going to let him get a free release off the line before someone decides to bump him a little? I realize the secondary is depleted, so maybe they should be doing something besides letting Philly's only viable receiving threat run free?
But what do I know, I'm not Tom Coughlin's bestest buddy in the whole wide world like Sheridan. Glad to see Coughlin gave him the old vote of confidence today, because when you're coaching a unit ranked 28th in the NFL, you're clearly doing a great job.
Curious about which four defense are worse? Chiefs, Bucs, Rams and Lions. Combined record of those four teams: 7-45.
And yes, the Browns defense is ranked ahead of the Giants.
Let me put this bluntly, Sheridan sucks, his defense sucks, and as a result, the Giants suck. Sheridan has made me forget all about how much I hate Kevin Gilbride, and that should tell you everything you need to know right there.
The defense had a chance to come up big in the fourth quarter, but instead allowed the Eagles to kill over seven minutes on a 12-play, 91-yard drive which was the football equivalent of the prison shower rape scene in American History X.
Amazingly, this team still has a reasonable chance at making the playoffs, which is a sad commentary on the depth of the NFC this year. With games left against the Redskins, Panthers and then Vikings (who will probably be resting players in Week 17) the Giants have an outside chance at finishing 10-6. With the Cowboys in the midst of their annual December collapse and the Giants holding the tiebreaker, that would probably be enough to sneak in.
It might not even take 10 wins, they could also probably get in at 9-7, but in looking at this team, would you even want them to? Assuming they got in as the 6th seed in the NFC, they would either play in Philly or in Arizona. The Eagles have scored 85 points against the Giants in two games, and Kurt Warner would be licking his chops if he got to face this defense out in Arizona. With Fitzgerald, Boldin and Breaston, the Cardinals might drop 60 on us.
The Giants will probably make the playoffs just to make us all sit through that on Wild Card weekend.
This F'ing team.





